diff --git a/apps/remix/app/components/general/envelope-editor/envelope-editor-invalid-direct-template-alert.tsx b/apps/remix/app/components/general/envelope-editor/envelope-editor-invalid-direct-template-alert.tsx
index 650c7e5a5..153db0a91 100644
--- a/apps/remix/app/components/general/envelope-editor/envelope-editor-invalid-direct-template-alert.tsx
+++ b/apps/remix/app/components/general/envelope-editor/envelope-editor-invalid-direct-template-alert.tsx
@@ -46,7 +46,7 @@ export const EnvelopeEditorInvalidDirectTemplateAlert = ({
 
         <ul className="list-disc pl-5">
           {signersMissingSignatureFields.map((recipient, i) => (
-            <li key={i}>{recipient.email || recipient.name || `Recipient ${i + 1}`}</li>
+            <li key={recipient.id}>{recipient.email || recipient.name || `Recipient ${i + 1}`}</li>
           ))}
         </ul>
       </AlertDescription>